| RED AND BLUE COLOR LEADERS | ||
| YEAR | REDS | BLUES |
| 1938 | E. McCardy | M. Hoffman |
| E. Myskens | W. Stevenson | |
| 1939 | M. Crosson | B. Batchler |
| G. Getchell | S. Bitzer | |
| 1940 | J. Cortright | M. Comly |
| F. Entwisle | H. Still | |
| 1941 | W. Griesinger | L. Harris |
| B. Murphy | H. Wambold | |
| 1942 | J. Poole | C. Redding |
| W. McCalla | A. Gaydon | |
| 1943 | A. Reese | M. L. Roberts |
| S. Lange | J. Fallows | |
| 1944 | M. Tribou | E. Carnahan |
| B. Carlile | P. Fitzgerald | |
| 1945 | G. Young | N. Evoy |
| J. Carnahan | T. Barry | |
| 1946 | E. Scott | B. Lane |
| G. Keller | D. Doyle | |
| 1947 | L. Farrow | L. Redding |
| J. Stevenson | N. Goldberg | |
| 1948 | S. Fitzgerald | J. Oswald |
| E. Nichols | J. Pullar | |
| 1949 | F. Geasey | E. Rice |
| B. Norton | F. Crampton | |
| 1950 | M. Rice | N. Schenkel |
| C. Burnes | J. Fox | |
| 1951 | A. Apfelbaum | I. Miller |
| H. Revotskie | C. Watts | |
| 1952 | P. Riggs | E. Silberman |
| J. Watts | D. Cramton | |
| 1953 | J. Skehan | J. Sturgeon |
| C. Strauch | B. Roy | |
| 1954 | B. DiJoseph | E. Klebe |
| B. Erickson | R. Craig | |
| 1955 | A. Carlile | L. Carlile |
| B. Moore | P. Schwehm | |
| 1956 | Margie Keene | Lora Wilt |
| Stody Watts | Bill Turner | |
| 1957 | Shirely Fish | Barbara Green |
| John Bird | John Highfield | |
| 1958 | Diane Thompson | Carolyn Harrar |
| Richard Hofman | Frank Tibbs | |
| 1959 | Flossie Jacobs | Linda Burd |
| Joe Reeder | George Sosnin | |
| 1960 | ||
| 1961 | Mary Fox Hesser | |
| Ed Barry | ||
| 1962 | Carol Ulberg | Liz Stevenson |
| Dave Murdock | Bob Lamberton | |
| 1963 | Betsy Tunnell | Ellen Miller |
| Tom Roth | Frank Sosnin | |
| 1964 | Marilyn Speidel | Nancy Duke |
| John Ulberg | Bert Sosnin | |
| 1965 | Shirley Lachman | Sue Pachuta |
| Bill Hoyt | Jim Molt | |
| 1966 | Phyllis Walton | Sue Armstrong |
| George Speidel | Rick Cline | |
| 1967 | Barb Gorham | June Eick |
| Lou Merlini | Joe Cappella | |
| 1968 | Sarah Smith | |
| Dave Fitzgerald | ||
| 1969 | Margaret Coon | Donna Heiss |
| Hank Plumly | Jack Stewart | |
| 1970 | Betsy Oliver | Martha Smith |
| Ron Christensen | Ed Waddington | |
| 1971 | ||
| ? Bob Hobby | ? Bob Hobby | |
| 1972 | ||
| 1973 | Nancy Armstrong | Consy Wheeler |
| Harold Hepler | Kevin Gravatt | |
| 1974 | Marcy Stwewart | Donna Walton |
| Bill Bergen | Perry Bartelt | |
| 1975 | ||
| 1976 | Sue Eichert | Marsha Spector |
| Steve Hallowell | Tom Ballantyne | |
| 1977 | Sue Hopf | Meg Felton |
| Chuck Barbieri | Bob DiValentino | |
| 1978 | Beth O'Connor | Lisa Ludovici |
| Dan Boutcher | Bob Closson | |
| 1979 | Diane Furlong | Leslie Henderson |
| Chris Mele | Alex Rae | |
| 1980 | Beth Hummell | Jeanette Curtis |
| Jerry O'Neill | Bob Barder | |
| 1981 | Debbie McCutcheon | Kerrie Hummell |
| Andy Bell | Jon Kuhl | |
| 1982 | Jessica Kolb | Missy Lynch |
| Greg Pierce | Alex Martin | |
| 1983 | Jacquie Curtis | Mary Ellen Furlong |
| Doug Rick | Dan Lindberger | |
| 1984 | Joanne Hopf | Barbara Damm |
| Bill Doheny | Scott Christino | |
| 1985 | Debbi Becker | Lea O'Boyle |
| Jason Kizel | Pat Furlong | |
| 1986 | Heather Luks | Dawn Chapman |
| Bill Pritz | Bill Parker | |
| 1987 | Joann McCann | Kristy Smith |
| Drew Stevenson | Rob Smith | |
| 1988 | Trish O'Brien | Candy Chapman |
| Ted Whalen | John Gerstemeier | |
| 1989 | Stefanie Van Dorick | Joanne Gerstemeier |
| Scott May | Cazzie Seweryn | |
| 1990 | Adrienne Dean | Evie Furse |
| Carl Dotger | Joe Gaglioti | |
| 1991 | Jen Unterberger | Rachel Cutler |
| Jim Clements | Adam Holland | |
| 1992 | Sandy Klein | Susan Bales |
| Jim Lindsay | Matt Totaro | |
| 1993 | Hilary Montgomery | Liz Wiseman |
| Jesse Katz | Pat Casey | |
| 1994 | Kate Nixon | Megan Montgomery |
| Mike Fitzgerald | Jason Maas | |
| 1995 | Kelly Brook | Aileen Haggerty |
| Jim Klein | Bob Bennett | |
| 1996 | Adrienne Richards | Rachel Connolly |
| Steve Eichert | Ed Oh | |
| 1997 | Sue Lahiff | Jessa DeSimone |
| Geoffrey Norbert | Ron Montgomery | |
| 1998 | Leslie Hudson | Lynn Stephan |
| Noah Marlier | Brian McCarthy | |
| 1999 | Ali Swiaki | Monica Mendoza |
| Nick diLeonardo | Andrew Park | |
| 2000 | Mia Oliver | Hannah DeSimone |
| Mike Galvin | Joe Righter | |
| 2001 | Neilly Oliver | Zoe Maas |
| Paul Remus | John Britton | |
| 2002 | Julia Hudson | Kate Totaro |
| AJ Juliani | Jim Romano | |
| 2003 | Jane Ockenlaender | Katie Forster |
| Tristian Norbert | Steve Baniewicz | |
| 2004 | Lee Oliver | Anna Morris |
| Ryan Heinig | Henry Sullivan | |
| 2005 | Allison Montanaro | Chelsea Feruzzi |
| Dori Even-Shoshan | Scott Stroup | |
| 2006 | Paige Oliver | Brenna Mulvaney |
| Alex Ridyard | Kyle Meier | |
| 2007 | Abby Juliani | Molly Mahoney |
| Phil Plumly | Jim Hughes | |
| 2008 | Jill Asher | Mara Mulvaney |
| Jason Reuter | Brian Cullen | |
| 2009 | Margo Koutsouradis | Karly Eyre |
| Jason West | Christopher Di Valentino | |
| 2010 | Laura Hill | Carolyn Smith |
| Sam Juliani | Nate Hall | |
| 2011 | Kelsey Rice | Courtney Smith |
| Christian Wall | Kent Charlemagne, Jr. | |